Sex Balancing in Thoroughbred Racing
How Important is Sex Balancing in Thoroughbred Breeding?
A study published in Reproduction, Fertility and Development in May 2015 by Xiang Lin and colleagues explored the role of maternal versus paternal influence on the racing ability of Thoroughbreds. The research analyzed 675 Australian Thoroughbreds, categorizing them into four groups based on the performance of their dam (mother) and sire (father). These groups were: Elite dam vs. Elite sire (EE), Elite dam vs. Poor sire (EP), Poor dam vs. Elite sire (PE), and Poor dam vs. Poor sire (PP).
The results showed that foals with Elite dams (EE and EP) performed similarly well, while foals with Elite sires (EE and PE) did not exhibit the same consistency. Interestingly, foals from Poor dams (PE and PP) consistently performed poorly, even if they had an Elite sire. This led the researchers to conclude that maternal influence, specifically through the dam’s mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), may have a stronger impact on racing ability than paternal genetics. Since mtDNA is inherited only from the mother and plays a key role in energy production (ATP), the study suggests that maternal heritability may be a more critical factor in athletic performance than previously thought, challenging the traditional focus on sire selection in breeding strategies.
The Sex Balance Report is a pivotal element in mating reports, particularly for breeders using services like Lone Star Stallions' mating reports. This report examines the genetic inheritance across nine generations, highlighting how often traits are passed down through the dam's (mother's) side versus the sire's (father's) side. The primary focus is on the balance of genetics, specifically how frequently traits are inherited from daughters (dam's line) versus sons (sire's line).
Federico Tesio, a renowned figure in thoroughbred breeding, proposed that foals inheriting the majority of their genetics from the sire line had a higher likelihood of becoming "plodders"—horses with less natural racing ability. This theory has been corroborated by over 5,500 validation studies and remains widely accepted by geneticists, software developers, and AI experts, including teams at Bloodhorse Agents. As a result, this theory is integrated into breeding tools like the Pedigrees360 Reports.
A key feature of these reports is the visual representation of the sex balance: when at least 33% of a foal's genetics come from the dam's line, it is highlighted in baby blue. This threshold is important because it relates to the role of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), which is only inherited from the mother. Mitochondrial DNA plays a crucial role in the horse's energy production, influencing the heart, lungs, and vascular system—all essential components for athletic performance. Breeders who prioritize the sex balance and understand the significance of mtDNA can make more informed decisions, optimizing their breeding for improved performance outcomes.
The Sex Balance Report not only offers valuable insights into the potential race performance of individual horses but has also proven highly accurate in predicting the success of stallions. A study conducted by the author over a year ago compared the Top 50 Stallions based on their Average Earnings Index (AEI) and Comparable Index (CI) to the Bottom 25 Stallions in the same categories. When the stallions' sex balance reports were analyzed, the results aligned perfectly with the stallions' rankings—those with favorable sex balances tended to perform better and remain among the top 50, while those with poor sex balances were more likely to be found in the bottom 25.
Understanding AEI and CI:
AEI (Average Earnings Index) is a statistical measure that compares a stallion's progeny earnings against the average earnings of all runners over a specific period. A stallion with an AEI above 1.00 is considered above average, with 1.50 being the benchmark for a high-performing stallion. The AEI is adjusted for the number of progeny a stallion has, allowing it to compare sires across different generations and foal crops.
CI (Comparable Index) measures the quality of mares bred to a particular stallion. It compares the offspring produced by these mares when bred to other sires, offering a gauge of the genetic quality of the mares in relation to the stallion's progeny. A CI of 2.19, for example, indicates that the mares produced offspring averaging 2.19 times the average for that generation when bred to other stallions.
For a stallion to be considered truly exceptional, its AEI should be higher than the CI of the mares he is bred to. This suggests that the stallion is "improving" the quality of the mares, producing better progeny than these mares would produce with other sires. Conversely, if the AEI is lower than the CI, it’s a red flag that the stallion may not be matching or exceeding the quality of progeny that his mares are capable of producing with other stallions.
How the Sex Balance Ties In:
The Sex Balance Report acts as an important predictor of a stallion's success by tracking how often genetics are passed down through the dam (mother) vs. the sire (father). This balance correlates with the overall mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) contribution, which affects critical athletic traits like heart size, lungs, and vascular system. Stallions with a more favorable sex balance often exhibit the traits linked to higher athletic performance in their progeny, leading to higher AEIs. This data-driven insight into sex balance has been incorporated into predictive tools like Pedigrees360, offering breeders an additional layer of valuable information when making breeding decisions.
In summary, the Sex Balance Report provides a unique, scientifically backed tool that can help predict a stallion’s future success in the breeding shed. When combined with the AEI and CI, it serves as a powerful indicator of the stallion’s ability to produce top-performing racehorses, helping breeders make more informed and strategic decisions.
The Sex Balance Report provides an insightful lens into a stallion's potential, as demonstrated by the examples of top runners who failed as sires versus those who succeeded. In the cases of several high-profile horses, it’s clear that their lack of consistent genetic influence passed down from the maternal line (the dam’s side) may have been a key factor in their failure to establish themselves as successful stallions.
Failed Stallions:
Always Dreaming
Achievements: Winner of both the Florida Derby and Kentucky Derby
Sex Balance: Only 2 instances where the genetics were passed down by the daughters at least 33% of the time.
Outcome: Despite his significant success on the racetrack, he has been a complete failure as a sire.
I’ll Have Another
Achievements: Another Florida Derby and Kentucky Derby winner.
Sex Balance: 2 instances where the genetics were passed down by the daughters at least 33% of the time.
Outcome: Similarly to Always Dreaming, this colt failed to make an impact as a stallion, which may be linked to the lack of strong maternal lineage influence.
Air Force Blue
Achievements: Multiple Grade 1 winner.
Sex Balance: 4 instances in which genetics were passed down by the daughters at least 33% of the time.
Outcome: Despite his high-class performance on the track, Air Force Blue didn’t establish himself as a top sire, potentially due to the insufficient maternal genetic influence.
Bodemeister
Achievements: Arkansas Derby winner.
Sex Balance: Only 4 instances where genetics were passed down by the daughters.
Additional Context: Bodemeister’s Average Earnings Index (AEI) was 58 points below his mares' Comparable Index (CI), suggesting that, despite being a good racehorse, he did not improve the quality of mares he was bred to. This mismatch, along with a low number of maternal instances, could have contributed to his failure as a sire.
Successful Stallions:
When comparing the above failed sires to some of the top stallions, it becomes clear that those with more than 5 instances of maternal genetic influence generally performed better as sires. The higher the instances where the maternal line contributed significantly, the greater the stallion’s success rate in passing on high-performance traits.
AP Indy
Sex Balance: 13 instances
Outcome: AP Indy, one of the most successful sires in recent years, clearly benefitted from a strong maternal influence in his progeny, helping him maintain dominance in the breeding shed.
Secretariat
Sex Balance: 14 instances
Outcome: Known for producing offspring who dramatically affected the breed, Secretariat’s influence from the dam line was unparalleled, making him one of the most influential sires in history.
Tapit
Sex Balance: 9 instances
Outcome: Tapit’s strong influence in the breeding shed is no accident—his ability to pass down key performance traits through his daughters helped cement his place as one of the leading sires in North America.
Arrogate
Sex Balance: 8 instances
Outcome: A major success in both racing and as a sire, Arrogate benefitted from a substantial maternal influence, which contributed to his reputation for producing high-quality progeny.
Gun Runner
Sex Balance: 7 instances
Outcome: As a successful young stallion, Gun Runner's maternal influence has been critical in producing fast, durable horses on the racetrack.
Justify
Sex Balance: 7 instances
Outcome: With a short but spectacular racing career and already showing promise as a sire, Justify’s success can be attributed in part to a strong maternal lineage.
Medaglia d'Oro
Sex Balance: 7 instances
Outcome: A consistent producer of top-level horses, Medaglia d'Oro's ability to pass down successful genetic traits from his maternal line has played a role in his success as a sire.
Key Takeaways:
Sex Balance Report and Maternal Influence:
The Sex Balance Report reveals a clear pattern: stallions with more than 5 instances of genetics being passed down from the maternal line (daughters) tend to perform better as sires, producing offspring with superior athletic traits. Strong maternal influence, indicated by baby blue boxes in the report, correlates with better breeding outcomes and success in the breeding shed.
Overcoming Shortfalls with the Right Mare:
A stallion with fewer maternal instances can still succeed by being matched with the right mare or family line. This is where Pedigrees360 comes in: Even if a stallion doesn’t seem like an ideal match on his own, when paired with a complementary mare, he can still produce elite racehorses. Pedigrees360 provides the insights to find these ideal pairings, optimizing your breeding strategy.
Examples of Top Stallions with Strong Maternal Lines:
Legendary sires like AP Indy, Secretariat, and Tapit all benefited from robust maternal lines, which helped elevate their Average Earnings Index (AEI) and establish them as top performers in the breeding world. Their strong maternal influence played a significant role in their ability to produce offspring that excelled on the racetrack.
The Downside of Fewer Maternal Instances:
On the flip side, stallions with fewer maternal instances—such as Always Dreaming, I’ll Have Another, and Air Force Blue—struggled to consistently produce high-quality offspring. This underscores the importance of maternal inheritance in determining a stallion’s success as a sire. Despite their racetrack success, these stallions did not consistently pass on the traits needed to produce top-tier racehorses, demonstrating that maternal influence is often the deciding factor in a stallion’s legacy.
The Critical Role of Maternal Genetics:
This finding supports the broader notion that maternal genetics play a critical role in shaping both race performance and a stallion’s legacy. By focusing on maternal lines and leveraging tools like Pedigrees360, breeders can make more informed decisions, increasing their chances of producing elite runners in the upcoming breeding season.
Conclusion:
By considering Sex Balance, maternal inheritance, and genetic compatibility, breeders can maximize their chances of success in the 2025 breeding season. Whether you’re working with strong stallions or those with fewer maternal instances, Pedigrees360 offers the tools to make the best mating decisions, ensuring that your breeding program produces the next generation of elite racehorses.
How Lonestar Stallions Can Help You with Your Breeding Plans for 2025
Visit Our Website:
Go to www.lonestarstallions.com/mating-reports.
Enter Your Mare(s) Information:
Input the names of your mare(s) and let our system do the work!
Our Matching Process:
Step 1: Stallion Match – We will first match your mare with our own roster of stallions. If your mare is a good fit, you’ll receive a detailed mating report with key information about the match.
Step 2: Expand to Other Stallions – If our stallions are not the ideal match, we will extend the search to include stallions from either Texas or Oklahoma, based on your preference.
Step 3: Top Three Matches – We provide you with detailed reports for the top three stallion matches, tailored to your mare’s breeding potential.
Absolutely No Cost:
This service is completely free for breeders! You’ll get detailed reports with no obligation to commit.
Why Choose Lone Star Stallions?
Expertise and Data: Our mating reports are built on years of experience and data-driven insights, helping you make informed breeding decisions.
Tailored Matches: Whether you prefer local Texas or Oklahoma stallions or are exploring wider options, our system helps you find the best fit for your mare, increasing your chances of a successful breeding season.
Whether you're looking to breed for speed, stamina, or other traits, Lone Star Stallions makes it easy to ensure your mare is matched with the right stallion for a successful 2025 season. Start today at no cost and let us help guide your breeding decisions!
